The ongoing Tribunal sitting over the kogi November 11th 2023 elections in Abuja beamed with life and emotions today as the All Progressives Congress, APC, closed her case with a star witness, Barr Ehimoni Joshua, whose style of response during cross examination drove SDP Counsel’s rage in court.
Ehimoni, who provided his membership card of APC, affirming his position as member of the Gubernatorial Campaign Council, also led as the Head of APC agents for the election.
In his revelation during cross examination by J.B Daudu, SAN, he revealed how many LGAs in Kogi East like Dekina were unsigned and unticked in the voters register, suggesting a gross manipulation of results. The documents produced were that of Olamaboro, Ankpa, Dekina, Ofu, Igalamela, and Idah LGAs.
During the SDPs cross examination, the Counsel challenged the witness on the authenticity of the FCT High Court affidavit deposed by the incumbent Governor, Ahmed Usman Ododo. Reacting, he noted that he could see a name on the document placed before him but was not in the position to confirm if it was a High Court affidavit.
Furthermore, the Counsel to the SDP requested the witness to confirm the date on the affidavit, which he said that date is validated by the date of payment. On insistence of the judge, he responded that the date was 2nd of December, 2023, which aggravated the petitioner Counsel who almost went into a brawl with the witness in the dock.
When he was cross examined on the BVAS machine, with the SDP Counsel asking him to read the last paragraph of the document before him, he responded “Power Bank”, which further aggravated the Counsel.
Find attached court extract for today’s sitting:
Cross Examination by J B Daudu.
JB.. Confirm the Documents placed before you on my request.
Witness…they are (1)INEC regulations and guidelines for 2023 election (2) Manual for Election officials (2023)
JB …are you familiar with the documents?
Witness yes
JB …did you at any time come into contact with these documents and in what capacity.
Witness… Yes, in the capacity of member of APC campaign council.at a seminar organised by INEC in respect of Nov 11 2023 Governorship election. and we were taught how to go about the exercise from accreditation to voting.
JB… confirm the BVAS report before you
Witness, yes it is and it’s signed by INEC staff named Siaka Aminetu of hard ware dpt.
JB….from your experience in the seminar, can More than 1 BVAS be used in a polling unit
Witness Yes, essentially to curtail previous experience where BVAS machine malfunctioned and disenfranchised eligible voters.Indeed more than one BVAS Machine is allocated to units with more than 400 registered voters.
JB….. Identify the documents before you. Witness….they are voters registers used in OLAMABORO, ANKPA, DEKINA, OFU IGMELA,and IDAH
JB……WHICH ONE IS TICKED
WITNESS.. that of Dekina, Abocho, and Iyale.
JB …….I suggest to you that most were not ticked
Witness …Yes.
Cross Examination by SDP Lawyers
SDP….You are a lawyer called to bar in 2008
Witness. Yes
SDP. Did you read the petition dated 22nd DEC 2023
WITNESS . I read the petition but the date you quoted is wrong.
SDP.. You are currently the DG BUREAU of public procurement Kogi state
Witness.. Yes
SDP.. Take a look at the documents placed before you on my request.
Witness….I have seen the document but it is not the document I referred to in my witness statement
SDP….is the document stamped and by who?
Witness… I can see the stamp, but I don’t know how it came about
SDP.. There is a space where Primary and Secondary School qualifications are supposed to be filled on page 4 of the document before you
Witness.. The document before me is not paged
SDP….Can you see that the column for primary and secondary sch is not filled
Witness.. There is no name in the document before me.
SDP….Confirm that the document before you is an affidavit deposed to by Ahmed Usman Ododo at the FCT high court.
Witness.. I can see the name but am not in a position to confirm the high court affidavit.
SDP… what is the date on that affidavit? you are a lawyer so answer my question…
Witness… answering as a lawyer, the date is validated by the date of payment.
Judge.. Pls answer as a witness
Witness… 2nd Dec. 2023
SDP…Were you in any of the poling units where you claimed there was no over voting
Witness… I need to be shown the documents where I made the statement to be sure.
Judge.. Please answer
Witness. I visited not less than 50 polling units and in all of the polling units there was no over voting,I was not in some polling units actual voting took place., the evidence I gave relied on the reports of INEC presiding officers at the polling Units.
SDP. ..Confirm that the function of BVAS machine as per the documents before you is that it contains the correct figure of accredited voters.
Witness.. I can’t see anything here
SDP.. ..What is the last statement in the paragraph I referred you to in the document before you.
Witness…the last statement is Power bank.
SDP COUNCEL Became very angry… What do you mean?
Witness. You said what is the last statement in the document and what I can see here is power bank.
Judge… Pls read out the function of BVAS machine as contained in the document
Witness. To store number of vote cast.
Compiled by Kogi Rebel
Akoni TV For your Socio-Politcial, Business, Sport and Entertainment News