Home / SocioPolitical / Court Resumes As SDP Witnesses Deny Membership, Over-Voting Claims

Court Resumes As SDP Witnesses Deny Membership, Over-Voting Claims

The ongoing Kogi Tribunal court, sitting in FCT, Abuja, comes back to life on Saturday, the 30th of March, 2024, after a 24 hours recess, with the cross examination of the Witnesses provided by the Social Democratic Party lawyers by the APC and INEC Lawyers.

The first Witness introduced was Isah AbdulGaniu from Okene, LGA, a Fashion designer.

Caught in the cross fire of cross examination by APC lawyers, the Witness denies being a Member of the SDP, which by law, an Agent of SDP is the legal status necessary to protest a result in any election. The fatal error by the SDP lawyers reveals how pre-packaging of Witnesses could hurt a case in court.

Reading from the witness count, four (4) other Witnesses denied Membership of the party, agreeing to sighting SDP agents by tags at the Polling Unit where they voted on the election day.

Furthermore, Abdulganiu denies knowledge of forms DCE-41 which was cardinal to his petition, suggesting in reality that the petition was written for him by the SDP Lawyers.

To lay further credence to this suspicion, he also attested to signing his petition in Lokoja, instead of Okengwe, his domicile of voting, which clearly shows the petition was carefully arranged by the SDP lawyers who alleged over-voting in his polling unit, however, failing to coach him properly on the fundamentals of the Oluwole arranged petition.

After many legal missiles from the counsel(s) to the Defendants and INEC, SDP withdrew the visibily confused Witness, introducing another witness, who denied over-voting claims of 584 in his petition, as he could produce the scores between APC and PDP on the day of Election, claiming he doesn’t know.

In addition, the second witness agreed before the court that due process were followed during the elections, providing a graphical testimony of how he sighted the Voters Register, BVAS Machine and submission of results sheets to SDP agents in his unit on election day.

Entertaining highlight of the meticulous Lawyers of the APC was when one of the witnesses was asked to mention the name of one of the most popular local Musicians in Okengwe, Alhaji Sule Adeku

Latw Alhaji Sule Adeku was a delight of the old and young in memories when it comes to deep eulogy of the culture of the Ebira people.

Below are selected Court Extracts from the witness inter-alia:

Witness 1

Isah AbdulGaniu who stays in Okene LGA, Fashion Designer by Profession.

Initial Witness statement Ref:OKN221: on 2/12/2023:

He was cross-Examined by the APC Counsel as thus:
Kanu Agabi asked him the following questions:

Kanu Agabi: Q1 . Do you know if SDP has an agent in that PU where you voted?

Witness Response: Yes

Q2: How do you know if he’s the SDP agent?

A: He saw the SDP tag on him.

Q3: Are you aware under the Law/guideline of INEC Election that it’s only the partyagentss that can protest?

Witness Responded; I don’t understand.

*The Other APC Lawyer took over:*
Q1: Did you write your statement by yourself or the Lawyers wrote it for you?

Witness Response: I wrote them by myself.

Q2: Did you read them again to be SURE that , it’s what you wrote?

A: YES

Q3: Do you know what DCE-41 is used for?

Witness Response: I don’t know.

Q4: Please, read out paragraph 5F: of your deposition: Witness reads it.

Q5: Have you participated in any election before?

Witness Response: Presidential Election.

Q6: You said you saw the BVAS Machine & the partyagentss in your PU?

Witness Response: Yes

Q7: On the day of the Election, the PO was there ; did you see the presiding officer screen shot the FORM EC8-A into the BVAS Machine:

Witness Response; Yes

Q8: Did you see the results given to any of these agents at the PU?

Witness Response: No
The witness was clearly confused.

*At this point the INEC lawyers took over the Cross-Examination*

Q1: On the day of election, did you play any other role than to vote?

A: No
Q2: You did not operate the BVAS Machine?

A: No
Q3: Your witness deposition, did you sign it in Okene or Lokoja?

A: I signed in Lokoja

Q4: You talked about over Voting, by what figure?

Witness responded that he couldn’t remember.

*Cross Examination on the 2nd witness continues: by another APC Counsel:*

Q1: What is your highest qualification?
A: Degree Certificate

Q2: Have you participated in any election before?
A: Yes

Q3: As a voter that you claim, are you aware that you’re supposed to stay back after the election to count the votes?

A: Yes

Q:4: On the day of Election, did you see and hear the PA, calling all the agents of the political parties to come forward?

Witness Response: Yes

Q5: Were you given a copy of FORM-CE8-A that day ?

Witness Response; No, he is not entitled to it.

Q6: Did you help the agents to fill the FORM-EC8-A that day?

A: NO
Q7: Did you see the Party Agents been given results after Election on that day?

A: it was given to them.

Q8: Did you see the copy of the register that day & it was used in the election that day?

Witness Response; Yes
Q8: Do you see the BVAS Machine that day? Was it used ?
A: It was used.

Q9: The over voting was 584, do you know the scores for APC & PDP results?

Witness Response; No, i don’t know.

*INEC counsel took over..*

Q1: On the Election day, were you in Okene town or Okengwe?

Witness Response : I was in Okengwe.

Q2: There used to be a popular local Musician from Okengwe; please can you tell the court? Alh. Sule Adeku Onukoko

Q3: In paragraph 5(A-G) due process were followed on the Election Day?

Witness Response: Yes
Q4: You admitted that SDP has an agent?

Witness Response; YES

Q5: Your complaints were based on what you heard?
Witness Response, Based on what he saw.
Q6: But a political party brought you here to testify?

A: Yes

Q7: Therefore , I will be correct to say you’re not a witness to SDP?

Witness Responded; YES, he is here to affirm his statement.
Q8: Who brought you here?

Witness Response; He came on his own.
Q9: I will be right to say you don’t know the petitioner of this case?

Witness Response; I came on my own.

Another lawyer, Alex E, asked the following questions:

Q1: Do you know you’re coming here today to testify as a witness at the Tribunal?

Witness Response; YES

Q2: Do you know the candidates?

A: No, but I see them in the posters

Q3: So your evidence is for these people you see in posters ; the witness responded by saying No.
That he didn’t not know his evidence will be used by the Tribunal if he testifies.

Q4; Did you see the VR that day and the number of voters registered to vote that day ?

Witness Response, No
Q5: Did you see FORM -EC8- A that day ?
Witness Response; He cannot remember.

*The INEC LAWYER asked the following questions*

Q1: Did you operate the BVAS Machine that day?

A: No

Q2: Did you remain in the place you voted?

A: No, I left the place
*Q3: *The figures that was announced that you’re protesting, are you sure you saw them at your PU* ?
Witness Responded; *He has eye problems for over a year now*
Q5: I put it to you that if you have eye problems, it means you’re not in the position to see scores on FORM-EC8-A.

Witness Response, I can’t remember. (*initially he said he couldn’t see*) cos of his eye problems for over one year now, which started before the Election.👆🏿

*Another witness No.6, Ibrahim Majeed from Okene LGA a painter, said the following when asked:*
Q1: you just told this court that BVAS machine was used on Election Day?

A, YES
Q2: *It will now be wrong for anybody to tell this Tribunal that BVAS Machine or VR was not used on Election Day?*
Witness Response *by saying YES*
Q3: Then you cannot tell what the parties scored?
A.YES
Q4: You also dont know the number of VOTERS ticked to vote on Election Day?
Witness Responded, No

*The sitting is adjourned to 1st of April, 2024*

Compiled by Kogi Rebel

About AkoniTV

Check Also

2027: Atiku Camp Warns No Southern Candidate Can Defeat Tinubu in Presidential Election

The camp of former Vice President Atiku Abubakar has warned opposition parties against zoning the ...