Home / SocioPolitical / SDP Runs Into Legal Confusion, Dumps Kogi Central Witnesses, Drags Kogi East Politician Into Witness Box

SDP Runs Into Legal Confusion, Dumps Kogi Central Witnesses, Drags Kogi East Politician Into Witness Box

The legal team of the Social Democratic Party, SDP, in the ongoing Kogi Tribunal Case sitting in FCT, challenging the November 11th gubernatorial victory of APCs Alhaji Usman Ododo have run into a legal ditch of no return.

In a clear reality of confusion, the SDP legal team have abandoned the witnesses from the five (5) LGAs of Kogi Central, where they are challenging the incumbent in an allegation of over-voting and the circumventing of the Bimodal Verification Accreditation System, BVAS machine. The lead counsel to the SDP Candidate, Alhaji Muritala Ajaka, realizing the damage done to the SDP petition from Kogi Central Witnesses, who all agreed to the use of BVAS Machine, citing of the Voter Register and accurate compliance to the electoral guidelines, with some contradicting themselves in oral testimony over their written addresses; Barr. Okutepa, SAN, in a legal somersault, abandons other witnesses from the district, dragging former Dekina Local Government Chairman and House of Representatives Member representing Dekina/Bassa in the Green Chamber from Kogi East and a card carrying member of the SDP, Hon. Ikani Benjamin Okolo; into the witness box. According to the petitioners, Ikani was amongst the SDP observers who inspected the BVAS machine as earlier granted by the Tribunal two months ago in Lokoja, with his petition submitted as evidence to support the SDP case.

In his submission, he attested to the authenticity of the BVAS brought to Court as the same he inspected about two months back.

Before the Dekina born politician was put on the stand, the court was delayed by frantic efforts by the Okutepa team, who kept making applications for substitution of figures, introducing new elements to their case, asking for BVAS to be brought back to the Court, a demand the Judge denied, allowing access to cite by the only witness provided by the SDP Team.

The level of confusion by the SDP team cannot be measured as at the time of documenting this court proceeding as we have seen in a short period of time, how the confused legal team introduced perjury allegations on the birth certificate of the incumbent Governor, circulating a fictitious document which was birthed out of Corel Draw imagination, sponsoring puerile attacks on the personality of the former Governor, His Excellency, Alhaji Yahaya Bello, sponsoring different formats of propaganda to prejudice the court, along with an unclear path of what the legal redress is darting in focus.

The Kogi East Politician was put on the witness box for more than one hour, with the petitioners trying to correct his written address before cross examination. The obviously disappointed witness, weary from how the SDP lawyers handled his evidence, climbed down from the box unhappy.

Attached is the court extract inter alia..:

Kanu Agabi, SAN, led the counsels for the APC.

*The first & only witness today for SDP was Benjamin Ikani Okolo* from AYINGBA in Dekina LGA of Kogi State, a politician and a card carrying member of SDP.

The witness requested that the figure *276,250 be changed to 276,750* in his deposition before adopting it as his evidence in this case and his request was granted even though APC counsels objected & reserved their reasons for objection.

The APC counsel took over to cross examine the witness, and Kanu Agabi asked him the following questions:

Q: How many LGAs & PUs are you challenging for the Election?
A: 5LGAs, but can’t confirm the PUs.
Q: There 2,540 PUs in Kogi, please confirm?
A: I can’t confirm
Q: Then, can you confirm how many PUs you are contesting their results?
A: I can’t confirm that.
Q: None of the results sheet were made by you?
A: Yes
Q: None of the documents identified today were recorded by you?
A: I didn’t record any, I only came in contact with them.
Q: You didn’t make any input to the BVAS devices.
A: I did not make any input
Q: One of the ground of your petition is that the election was invalid?
A: That’s very correct.

Q: One of the relief that SDP is seeking is that you won the election & should be declared the winner, you want to be declared a winner of an Election that was Invalid?
A: Witness response with other explanations, but he was asked to answer Yes or No, but didn’t say anything
Q: Do SDP have agents in all the PUs?
A: YES, They have across the state.
Q: your observations were contained in your deposition?
A: Yes
Q: You didn’t distinguish your observations & the report you received from your agents?
A: I didn’t separate, but the report shows the whole observations made.

*Another APC counsel took the cross examination*
Q: Do you know that your report covers all the PUs that SDP is complaining about?
A; YES
Q: You were not in Adavi, Okene, or any where In the Central Zone and LKJ ?
A: Yes, I was in Kogi East
Q: Take a look at your deposition. Is there any signature of INEC staff on that report?
A: No, there’s no INEC staff signature on it.
Q: I’ve looked at the report if I tell you that a large %age of your report is not correct based on your observations, will you agree?
A: No, I won’t agree.
Q: Pls, go to Page 153 of your statement of oath, IRO Adavi LGA, PU.No1; front of Victory School, APC scored- *405 per your stnt on oath*. Go to your report on page 33: the same PU is shown to *have scored 410 for APC*.
A: YES, 410, he said 418 initially.
Q: In LKJ LGA, the first one you stated in your statement of Oath: PU023 (Lokogoma LKJ) ; The over voting figure was stated to be *22votes* on Page159. Show us PU1, 2, 3 ; those PUs were not reflected in your report?
A: It is not reflected as it was discovered that there were no over voting in those PUs.

*Now the INEC Lawyer takes over the Cross examination*
Q: your figures on statement of Oath is not correct?
A: It’s correct based on the information at my disposal.

Q: Are you aware that an INEC staff was here to demonstrate the figures in the BVAS Machine to this Honorable Tribunal?
A: Yes, I’m aware
Q: Will you be surprised to hear that from AJK, serial number: 2,8,9,10, 11 & 21 on your *page 159* in your witness statement are not correct.
A: What I have is correct.

Q: For Okehi LGA like above; serial number: 2 & 3 the figures there does not match with the BVAS machine figures earlier displayed by the INEC staff .
A: I can’t confirm.

Q: I want to draw your attention again to your statement that the figures referred to for: serial Number: 47, 48, 50 & 51 do not conform with the figures displayed by the INEC staff in the BVAS machine. Meaning the figures are not consistent per your claim.
A: I cannot confirm them.
Q: IRO Okeke LGA; with particular reference to serial Number; 20, 23; 24 & 26 , the acrdited figures in your statement of Oath are not consistent with the numbers displayed by the INEC staff.
A: My answer is the same, I can’t confirm
Q: I suggest to you that the figures you want this Honorable Tribunal to rely on in pages 153 to declare you (SDP) winner is not correct in reference to the BVAS Machine figures.
A: I did not make any statement that is inconsistent.

At this point the SDP lawyer Okutepa applied that the witness be discharged from the witness Box.

*The Tribunal sitting was adjourned to Friday 5th April, 2024*

Compiled by Kogi Rebel

About AkoniTV

Check Also

2027: Atiku Camp Warns No Southern Candidate Can Defeat Tinubu in Presidential Election

The camp of former Vice President Atiku Abubakar has warned opposition parties against zoning the ...